Cars America

1. Don't pay or agree to anything on the first call

   Get the company's name, mailing address and the account number they're using. In many states a payment, or even a promise to pay, can restart the clock on an old debt.

2. Watch the mail for a validation notice

   Within five days of first contacting you, Cars America has to send a notice showing the amount, the creditor and a dispute deadline at least 30 days out. If you never got one, that is worth noting in writing.

3. Dispute in writing before that deadline

   Ask them to prove the debt. Once they receive a written dispute in time, they must stop collecting until they mail you verification. Write the letter here, then send it by certified mail.

4. Check your credit reports

   Get all three free at AnnualCreditReport.com. If a collection account is wrong, dispute it with the credit bureau as well as the collector.

5. Never ignore court papers

   If you're served with a lawsuit, file a response by the deadline on the summons. If you don't, the collector usually wins by default and can then ask to garnish wages. What to do if you're sued.

1. Threatened or took negative or legal action89% · 23
2. Collecting a debt the person says they don't owe7.7% · 2
3. False or misleading statements3.8% · 1

The specific problems

The single most common complaint is “threatened or suggested your credit would be damaged” (89%).

Most people who complained didn't know what kind of debt Cars America was collecting. The validation notice must name the original creditor.

1. Texas15%
2. Georgia15%
3. Florida12%
4. North Carolina12%
5. Michigan7.7%
6. California7.7%
7. Pennsylvania7.7%
8. Ohio7.7%
9. Nevada3.8%
10. Missouri3.8%

State laws add to the federal rules, and some states require collectors to hold a license. Pick your state above for its time limits and license lookup.

Closed with an explanation only

0%

Fixed something, no money back

0%

Money back or debt reduced

0%

Answered on time

0%

Cars America gives some kind of relief in 0% of complaints, less often than the average collector (23%). A complaint alone may not fix things; a written dispute protects your rights either way. "Relief" usually means correcting a credit report, stopping collection or closing the account.

Use the phone number and mailing address printed on the letter Cars America sent you, and send disputes to that address. We don't list phone numbers because scammers often call pretending to be real collectors, and caller ID can be faked.

Not sure the caller is really Cars America? Ask for a written validation notice, then call the number on the company's own website or on your original account statements. A real collector won't demand payment by gift card, wire transfer or crypto.

A collector can't report a debt to the credit bureaus until it has contacted you about it. If Cars America shows up on your report:

• Check the details. The amount, the original creditor and the date of first delinquency should match your records.
• Dispute errors with each bureau. Equifax, Experian and TransUnion must investigate, usually within 30 days.
• Know the seven-year limit. It runs from when the original account first went delinquent. Paying doesn't reset it, and a collector can't legally "re-age" it.
• Disputed debts must be marked. If you dispute with Cars America, it must report the debt as disputed.

Collections, credit scores and pay for delete, explained

• Tri-State Adjustments3 / yr
• Robinson & Hoover6 / yr
• Red Target8 / yr
• Nexum Group6 / yr
• Main Street Holdings24 / yr
• Kirschenbaum & Phillips5 / yr